8 Best Shaving Soaps Get Reviewed: Insider’s Opinion

For adult men, there is no escape. Like it or not they have to shave at least twice a week. One can either use shaving soap or cream for this. Shaving soaps are liked for the traditional wet shaving experience they offer.

The best shaving soap produces a rich, creamy and moisturizing lather that gives smooth shaving without razor cuts or itching. Soaps come in different varieties and you need to choose your personal best by knowing what they are made for, reading reviews, and pros and cons.

 

Images
Men’s Soap Company Shaving Soap for Men and Women 4.0 oz Refill Puck Made with Natural Vegan Plant Ingredients. Shea Butter and Vitamin E Create...
Proraso Shaving Soap in a Bowl, Sensitive Skin, 5.2 Oz
Van Der Hagen Scented Shave Soap - 3 Pack (3.5oz)
Col. Conk Worlds Famous Shaving Soap, Bay Rum (Net Weight 2.25 Oz)
D.R.Harris & Co Arlington Mahogany Shaving Bowl & Shaving Soap 100g
Title
Men’s Soap Company Shaving Soap for Men and Women 4.0 oz Refill Puck Made with Natural Vegan Plant Ingredients. Shea Butter and Vitamin E Create...
Proraso Shaving Soap in a Bowl, Sensitive Skin, 5.2 Oz
Van Der Hagen Scented Shave Soap - 3 Pack (3.5oz)
Col. Conk Worlds Famous Shaving Soap, Bay Rum (Net Weight 2.25 Oz)
D.R.Harris & Co Arlington Mahogany Shaving Bowl & Shaving Soap 100g
Images
Men’s Soap Company Shaving Soap for Men and Women 4.0 oz Refill Puck Made with Natural Vegan Plant Ingredients. Shea Butter and Vitamin E Create...
Title
Men’s Soap Company Shaving Soap for Men and Women 4.0 oz Refill Puck Made with Natural Vegan Plant Ingredients. Shea Butter and Vitamin E Create...
Images
Proraso Shaving Soap in a Bowl, Sensitive Skin, 5.2 Oz
Title
Proraso Shaving Soap in a Bowl, Sensitive Skin, 5.2 Oz
Images
Van Der Hagen Scented Shave Soap - 3 Pack (3.5oz)
Title
Van Der Hagen Scented Shave Soap - 3 Pack (3.5oz)
Images
Col. Conk Worlds Famous Shaving Soap, Bay Rum (Net Weight 2.25 Oz)
Title
Col. Conk Worlds Famous Shaving Soap, Bay Rum (Net Weight 2.25 Oz)
Images
D.R.Harris & Co Arlington Mahogany Shaving Bowl & Shaving Soap 100g
Title
D.R.Harris & Co Arlington Mahogany Shaving Bowl & Shaving Soap 100g

 

What is Shaving Soap?

Shaving soap is a concentrated mixture of fatty acids that produces thick lather when whipped using a shaving brush. The lather is coated on the face for lubrication and protection when shaving.

 

Why Use The Best Shaving Soap Instead of Shaving Cream?

Below are reasons you should start using shaving soaps instead of creams.

  • Shaving soaps last longer
  • They have a less lingering scent
  • They cost less
  • Unscented shaving soaps are available

 

Ingredients Used in A Shaving Soap

A typical shaving soap that contains a series of organic and inorganic padding and conditioning ingredients. These include humectants such as Glycerin and Shea Butter and base oils such as coconut oil and vegetable oils such as soybean and palm oil. The inorganic ingredients can be Titanium Dioxide, Potassium Stearate, Pentasodium Pentetate, and Tetrasodium Etidronate.

 

Different Shaving Soap Bases: Which One Is Better?

The most common shaving soap bases are Tallow, Glycerine, Vegetable oil, and Lanolin. The tallow based soaps are made from animal fat derivatives and they create superior lather. But these might clog pores. Glycerine based soaps might use animal fat but are largely produced from a combination of shea butter, coconut oil, argan oil, olive oil, Moroccan oil etc.

Glycerine based shaving soaps produce less lather. Vegetable oil based soaps use oils such as soybean, and canola. Lanolin soaps are made from the waxy oil secreted from sebaceous glands of sheep. Vegetable based soaps are better than all of them as these made from natural oils which keeps the skin soft and fresh,

 

Different Types of Shaving Soaps

Shaving soaps can be hard or soft. The hard types were first created during world war I and their modifications are still liked by people. The key ingredients used in the making of these soaps include tallow derived from mutton or beef fat, sodium hydroxide, and potassium hydroxide.  Soft soaps, on the other hand, are made from alkali ingredients and these have a creamy consistency which makes them easy to apply on the face.

 

Shaving Soap or Shaving Cream: Which One is Better?

Both shaving cream and shaving soaps soften facial hair protecting skin from sharp razor blades. Traditional shaving creams contain natural oils which soothe the skin while soft shaving soaps creamy texture moisturizes the skin. A good lathering technique is needed to use a shaving soap where good quality shaving cream creates easy and quick rather than the soap.

Both provides nice cushion and lubrication for a perfect shaving experience. It is your choice of preference what to use on your skin, traditional shaving cream tube or a hard long-lasting shaving soap. Go for your own choice, which variety or which brand suits you the most whether it is shaving cream or soap.

 

Summary Review: Top 3  Shaving Soaps

You have to give special attention to the shaving soap you use to avoid razor cuts, itching, and infection. Your goal should be to get the best shaving soap on the market. But since there are so many soaps available, you might be confused about what soap to buy. To help you we have compiled a list of best 8 shaving soaps. Any of these have the potential to give you a perfect shave and protect your skin after.

 

Top Pick 1: Men’s Soap Company Shaving Soap

Men’s Soap Company Shaving Soap for Men and Women 4.0 oz Refill Puck Made with Natural Vegan Plant Ingredients. Shea Butter and Vitamin E Create...
1,640 Reviews
Men’s Soap Company Shaving Soap for Men and Women 4.0 oz Refill Puck Made with Natural Vegan Plant Ingredients. Shea Butter and Vitamin E Create...
  • Subtle Himalaya scent: many of our customers have described the scent as mild and delightful that is not overpowering. The scent has earthy smell while it is fresh and not flowery. Women tend to love how a man smells after using the Himalaya soap.
  • All natural and minimal ingredients: our shave soap is made of the best naturally derived vegan plant ingredients. We do not use toxins, parabens, sulphates, or dyes. These high quality ingredients will leave your face feeling buttery smooth.
  • Thick and creamy lather: you can whip a nice, thick creamy lather in 15 seconds that provides fantastic glide and protection. The rich lather and thick foam provides a coating that leads to a smooth shave. Your razor can be rinsed cleanly without having to brush out the blades between shaving strokes.

This is a premium quality, denser lather producing shaving soap that gives a luxurious shaving experience. It has a mild smell and is enriched with shea butter, glycerin, and other natural ingredients to leave a well-conditioned skin after shaving.

Beardstyle Product Rating: 9.8/10

 

Top Pick 2: Proraso Shaving Soap

Proraso Shaving Soap in a Bowl, Sensitive Skin, 5.2 Oz
4,983 Reviews
Proraso Shaving Soap in a Bowl, Sensitive Skin, 5.2 Oz
  • It is designed for those who prefer the traditional method of using a shaving brush
  • Recommended for daily use

This is a gentle shaving soap with menthol that leaves a soothing effect on the skin. It is formulated for sensitive skin. It produces rich lather that softens the beard and moisturizes the skin.

Beardstyle Product Rating: 9.5/10

 

Top Pick 3: Arko Stick Shaving Soap

This is a soap that comes in a stick form. It is priced low compared to other soaps but offers premium quality shaving experience. It produces creamy lather, has a traditional scent and lasts for long.

Beardstyle Product Rating: 9.5/10

 

8 Best Shaving Soap To Buy In 2021: Extensive Reviews

 

1. Men’s Soap Company Shaving Soap

Men’s Soap Company Shaving Soap for Men and Women 4.0 oz Refill Puck Made with Natural Vegan Plant Ingredients. Shea Butter and Vitamin E Create...
1,640 Reviews
Men’s Soap Company Shaving Soap for Men and Women 4.0 oz Refill Puck Made with Natural Vegan Plant Ingredients. Shea Butter and Vitamin E Create...
  • Subtle Himalaya scent: many of our customers have described the scent as mild and delightful that is not overpowering. The scent has earthy smell while it is fresh and not flowery. Women tend to love how a man smells after using the Himalaya soap.
  • All natural and minimal ingredients: our shave soap is made of the best naturally derived vegan plant ingredients. We do not use toxins, parabens, sulphates, or dyes. These high quality ingredients will leave your face feeling buttery smooth.
  • Thick and creamy lather: you can whip a nice, thick creamy lather in 15 seconds that provides fantastic glide and protection. The rich lather and thick foam provides a coating that leads to a smooth shave. Your razor can be rinsed cleanly without having to brush out the blades between shaving strokes.

It is a Himalaya puck scented soap with a buttery texture. It contains shea butter, glycerin, coconut oil and Vitamin E that softens even the roughest of beards to facilitate a clean slippery shave. These ingredients also thoroughly moisturize and condition the skin.

 

Men's Soap Company Shaving Soap
Men’s Soap Company Shaving Soap
OPINION
It is a gentle, thick and fatty lather producing soap with a mild scent. It is slightly expensive but is worth it because of its high-quality ingredients.
PROS
Protects the skin
Creates thick lather
Doesn’t leave residue
CONS
Scent is almost non-existent
Priced a bit higher
9.8
Excellent
buy now

 

2. Proraso Shaving Soap

Proraso Shaving Soap in a Bowl, Sensitive Skin, 5.2 Oz
4,983 Reviews
Proraso Shaving Soap in a Bowl, Sensitive Skin, 5.2 Oz
  • It is designed for those who prefer the traditional method of using a shaving brush
  • Recommended for daily use

This is an Italian made shaving soap formulated for people with sensitive skin. It produces a thick and creamy lather that softens facial hair, skin and causes no irritation. The soap is free of mineral oils, silicons, parabens, and artificial colors.

 

Proraso Shaving Soap
OPINION
It is a premium quality soap that offers extra protection for people with sensitive and dry skin. Also, it lathers up nicely, gives a clean shave and leaves a cooling effect in the end.
PROS
Smells clean and fresh
Easy to produce lather
Does not dry face after shaving
Menthol produces cooling effect
CONS
Has a menthol scent which some might not like
Bit expensive
9.5
Awesome
buy now

 

3. Arko Stick Shaving Soap

This is a shaving soap in the stick form that becomes wrapped in a classic looking covering. It has a barbershop like the smell, produces a rich lather and is gentle on skin.

 

Arko Stick Shaving Soap
OPINION
It is the best value cheap shaving soap available on the market that performs way better than one would expect. It lathers nicely, for some the two sticks lasted for a year and comes with a classic aftershave smell.
PROS
Lasts Long
Easy to carry and use while traveling
Cheaper in price compared to others
Leaves a good smell after shaving
CONS
Scent is old-fashioned
Dries quickly
9.5
Amazing
buy now

 

4. Van Der Hagen Men’s Luxury Scented Soap

Sale
Van Der Hagen Scented Shave Soap - 3 Pack (3.5oz)
6,617 Reviews
Van Der Hagen Scented Shave Soap - 3 Pack (3.5oz)
  • THE SCENTED LUXURY SHAVE SOAP - is your ticket to a relaxing shave, as the subtle, fresh scent floats over the peaks and valleys of your skin.
  • PRODUCED IN OUR UNIQUE KETTLE PROCESS - Scented Shave Soap is ideal for a satisfying and luxurious lather for your wet shave. Enriched with soothing and natural ingredients - this lightly scented shaving soap provides a layer of protection for your face.
  • FOR ALL SKIN TYPES - Whether you’ve got dry, sensitive or acne prone skin, this cocoa butter shave soap will give you a close, smooth and irritation-free shave and skin that smells great all day.

It is the USA made, vegetable oil based shaving soap with added 10% glycerin. It has hypoallergenic ingredients that keep the skin, rash and itch free. It leaves the skin smooth and soft after every shave.

 

Van Der Hagen Men’s Luxury Scented Soap
OPINION
This shaving soap is great for someone who wants a naturally made shaving soap.It has a nice subtle fragrance, produces thick lather and lasts for months. Unlike many shaving soaps that come with mediocre packaging, this arrives in an elegantly packed box.
PROS
Better priced compared to others
Produces lather quickly
Blade glides nicely
Lasts for months
CONS
Can be allergic to some
Needs extra rinsing at the end
9
Amazing
Buy Now

 

5. Williams Mug Shaving Soap

This is a popularly used inorganic shaving soap that produces a light and airy foam. It is made in the USA and uses environment-friendly ingredients. It has an old barbershop like smell that lasts for a few minutes.

 

Williams Mug Shaving Soap
OPINION
Despite its low price tag, Williams Mug Shaving soap gives a smooth and clean shave. It lasts for long and fits the soap bowl nicely.
PROS
Lasts Long
Leaves skin soft and moisturized
Offers skin protection
High quality and eco-friendly ingredients used
CONS
Less lathers compared to other soaps
Smells mediocre
9
Amazing
buy now

 

6. Col. Conk Worlds Famous Shaving Soap

Sale
Col. Conk Worlds Famous Shaving Soap, Bay Rum (Net Weight 2.25 Oz)
1,347 Reviews
Col. Conk Worlds Famous Shaving Soap, Bay Rum (Net Weight 2.25 Oz)
  • Bay Rum Scent
  • Contains: Contains: Avocado Oil and Vitamin E
  • Net Weight 2.25 oz.

It is a bay rum scented shaving soap with Vitamin E and Avacado Oil.

 

Col. Conk Worlds Famous Shaving Soap
OPINION
Other than the downside of it being given with a cheap plastic container, this shaving soap does a fairly good job of giving a clean shave. The good about this is it has organic ingredients that pamper the skin after shaving.
PROS
Reasonably priced
Easily and quickly lathers up
Lather lasts longer on face
Needs less water to rinse
CONS
Container is made of cheap plastic
Smell is not great
8.5
Best
buy now

 

7.  D.R.Harris & Co Arlington Mahogany  Shaving Soap

D.R.Harris & Co Arlington Mahogany Shaving Bowl & Shaving Soap 100g
39 Reviews
D.R.Harris & Co Arlington Mahogany Shaving Bowl & Shaving Soap 100g
  • SHAVE SOAP: D. R. Harris & Co.’s shaving soaps are high-quality, pure white soaps
  • ARLINGTON: contains notes of lemon, bergamot, orange, neroli, rose, and musk
  • TRIPLE-MILLED: and specially formulated to be long-lasting and produce a rich, beard-softening lather

This is a triple milled, white shaving soap that produces thick and creamy lather. It comes in a dark wooden bowl. The soap’s scent comes from fern and citrus added to it.

 

D.R.Harris & Co Arlington Mahogany Shaving Soap
D.R.Harris & Co Arlington Mahogany Shaving Soap
OPINION
Other than the downside of a small bowl that it comes in, it is a great soap for every day shave. It lasts for long and has a strong citrusy smell. It produces great lather to give an extra smooth shave
PROS
Produces creamy lather
Lasts for 8 to 12 months
Smell is strong and masculine
CONS
Takes focused effort to lock lid in place
Soap leaves little lather in bowl
8.5
Best
buy now

 

8. Lather & Wood Shaving Soap

Sale
Lather & Wood Shaving Soap - Barbershop - Simply The Best Luxury Shaving Cream - Tallow - Dense Lather with Fantastic Scent for The Worlds Best Wet...
3,929 Reviews
Lather & Wood Shaving Soap - Barbershop - Simply The Best Luxury Shaving Cream - Tallow - Dense Lather with Fantastic Scent for The Worlds Best Wet...
  • LARGE 4.7oz SHAVE SOAP. A premium tallow based shaving soap for literally pennies a day. Get MONTH-after-MONTH of daily wet shaving satisfaction. Perfect with your favorite shaving brush and safety razor, multi-blade, or straight razor for the more daring type.
  • HAND CRAFTED IN SMALL BATCHES To Insure Highest Quality Possible. As wet shaving enthusiasts we have used all the major and micro brand shaving soaps, and this soap is nothing short of perfection.
  • CLEAN, CRISP BARBERSHOP SCENT - This Barbershop Shaving Soap has a delightful scent. Clean and refreshing, not too strong, but subtlety lingers long after your shave. Pairs Perfectly with Lather & Wood’s Barbershop Pre-Shave Oil and Barbershop Aftershave Balm.

This is a sandalwood scented shaving soap rich in shea butter and Tallow that give an extremely smooth shave and leave a classic aftershave smell. It protects skin from skin irritation, razor bumps and moisturizes it.

 

Lather & Wood Shaving Soap
Lather & Wood Shaving Soap
OPINION
It gives a clean and refreshing shave at a low price. The large 4.7oz soap lasts for months and creates a thick, creamy lather with fewer air bubbles.
PROS
Fresh smelling
Glides smoothly with the razor
Creates lather easily
Lasts for a long time
CONS
Lather is like clay not creamy
Leaves a burning sensation
8
Great
buy now

 

Final Verdict:

Among the 8 best shave soaps, we picked Men’s Soap Company Shaving Soap as the best shaving soap of all.

the best value product
Men’s Soap Company Shaving Soap
this soap really aces in all aspects including size, lather, scent, conditioning, ingredients, and as a moisturizer.
Pros
Good lather
Skin protection
Non-greasy
Cons
Mild scent
Pricey
9.8
excellent
buy now

 

How to Build Lather from A Shaving Soap?

  1. Wet your brush by placing it under running hot water or in a bowl of hot water until the brush brittles are soaked
  2. Using circular motions lather up the soap in a bowl. Do this until the initial bubbles disappear and a thick lather forms. This should take around 30 seconds.
  3. In case you got short on lather in between the shaving process, add more hot water and repeat the steps.
  4. Note: Badger hair brush is best suited for building lather from a shaving soap.

 

Additional Products You Need to Use Along with Shaving Soap

Things you need for shaving other than the best shaving soap are

  • Double-edged safety razor
  • Badger Hair Brush
  • Shave mug or bowl
  • Spare Blades
  • Aftershave lotion
  • Brush stand

 

FAQs

Q.What is artisan shaving soap?

Ans: Artisan shaving soaps are made by a batch of small business workers using the minimal equipment. So it is eco-friendly and does not depend on third world country workers. The significant portion of profits made of these soaps goes into building communities and maintaining economic security.

Q. Are shaving soaps cruelty-free?

Ans: The tallow and lanolin shaving soaps use animal fat and could be made after animal trials. There are also vegan shaving soaps that are made from only plant-based matter.

Q.Do shaving soaps contain natural scents?

Ans: Yes the best shaving soaps contain essential oils that give the scent

Q. What are different scents that a shaving soap could have?

Ans: The best shaving soap could have Bay Ray Bum, Sandalwood, Cedar, Fir, Citrus or others.

Q. Are there shaving soaps made for sensitive skin?

Ans: Yes, Poraso Shaving Soap is a good one.

 

After going through a long process of researching about various shaving soaps, we came up with the list of best 8 shaving soaps. Shaving soaps can vary in terms of many aspects. Some are made for giving that classic shave and others might be crafted for sensitive skin.

Depending on what you have been using in the past, what type of skin you have, the scent you like, and how much lather you prefer, you have to choose the right shaving soap. Any of the above soaps we have introduced should give you the perfect shave you dream of.

Last update on 2021-07-16 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Reply